Community migration · 08
How to move paid Substack readers to Telegram without charging twice
Keep paid time intact when moving from Substack to a private Telegram community. Track renewal, access and the new start date separately.

Monthly · web
Paid through 8 December; renewal off. Offer the new checkout after that date.
Annual · iOS
Paid through 31 March. Confirm renewal with Apple and preserve the paid time.
Status unclear
Check the original billing record first. Don’t send a checkout link yet.
Fictional examples. Confirm the time zone and the exact paid-through time for each reader.
Decide whether you’re moving the conversation or the billing
If you only want a place for readers to talk, keep existing Substack billing and verify eligibility before inviting them to a separate private Telegram space. You can launch Telegram as a new offer for new members while existing readers finish their current period. If you’re moving billing too, tell readers which service will charge them and when before you ask them to switch.
Record the last paid day and next charge separately
Use Substack’s Subscribers dashboard to filter and export the relevant list. Treat it as your roster, not permission to charge. A paid segment can include gift, complimentary and trial access. In a private tracker, record the verified paid-through date, original billing channel, renewal status and planned earliest date for new billing. If dates disagree, pause that reader’s handoff and check the original account or receipt; don’t infer a date from the word ‘annual.’
Preserve access before you turn off renewal
Ask readers renewing on the web to manage the subscription in Substack. Its help center explains that a web cancellation leaves access until the paid period ends; readers who subscribed in the iOS app cancel through Apple. The publisher’s Remove action is different: Substack says it cancels and prorates a refund for paying readers. Don’t use it as a shortcut to stop renewal. If paid content is moving now, use a separately verified temporary access method or keep old access available for the time already paid. A link’s expiry doesn’t itself set the expiry of someone’s membership.
Offer the new checkout only at the handoff
Tell each cohort the paid-through date, what it can access until then, and the earliest new charge date. Use an approved private invitation or join request when granted access must be verified. Test a monthly web reader, an annual Apple reader and someone with an unknown date before using the process broadly. A native Stars subscription is another paid-channel route, but don’t assume it carries over existing billing. If you choose Kinsi for new sales, treat its offer as a separate opt-in and confirm the actual join and access flow before sending it.
You have access through [date and time, time zone]. Until then, use [access instructions]. Your old renewal is [status]. If you want to stay afterward, the new subscription costs [price and interval] and starts only when you sign up from [earliest date]. If your billing record shows a different date, reply before paying.Audit member access →